Computers and music
by Robert A. Moog
Robert A. Moog is the inventor of the
practical music synthesizer and president of Big Briar, Inc., a
Leicester, North Carolina, firm specializing in the design of custom
For some of us, the idea of an electronic muse is scary; after all, music is an essentially human activity, while electronic equipment, especially the computer, is "mechanical" and "unnatural." Throughout history, however, music has been closely linked to technology. Except for the human voice, the instruments of music-making have always been "high tech" in their time.
The Electronic Muse
The violin, pipe organ and trumpet are complex constructions that were as "unnatural" when they were first developed as the computer is today. The piano and saxophone, those vital elements of our musical experience, were triumphs of manufacturing technology a century ago. Musical instrument designers have always employed the most advanced technology of their time. Now, in our time, electronic and computer technologies are preferred for new musical instrument development.
But this is not to say that musicians are embracing electronics just because it's the "latest thing." As a group, musicians favor instruments that a) sound good and b) offer musically useful ways of manipulating sound. Increasingly, musicians are drawn to electronic instruments-not because they're easy to play or sound like traditional acoustic instruments, but because they offer new tone colors and new ways of making music.
What's more, musicians have been experimenting with electronic instruments ever since the vacuum tube was invented three-quarters of a century ago. Even before that, musicians and musical instrument builders were collaborating to harness the forerunners of electronics and computers to the service of the muse.
For a growing number of musicians, computer technology is the greatest advance since the invention of catgut. Music is a form of communication-of organizing and transmitting data. The "alphabet" of music consists of notes. Melodies, chords and rhythmic patterns are the "words" and "phrases" of music. Just as computers can generate "characters" to make text or a graphic design, they can also process a stream of numbers that represent a sound waveform. And just as word processing programs endear computers to wordsmiths, today's composers, performers and music teachers are all exploring the computer's ability to handle musical information.
If you understand the general principles of computer operation and if you like to listen to music, you'll have no trouble following the many ways that digital technology and computers can be used to make music. Just keep in mind that computer music is a natural extension of traditional music and uses programs that are only slightly different from your basic word processor or data handler. As we shall see, simulating a multitrack recording studio on your monitor screen is done with software that is directly related to the program used to "compose" this article.
All sounds, musical or otherwise, are vibrations of the air, at rates of roughly 20 to 20,000 times a second. If the vibrations repeat regularly, the sounds are pitched (like a guitar or clarinet tone). If a sound vibration does not repeat regularly, then it sounds pitchless or "noisy" (like a cymbal crash). In a pitched sound, the rate of repetition is called its frequency; the greater the frequency, the higher the musical pitch of the tone. The strength of a vibration is called its amplitude; the greater a sound's amplitude, the louder it is.
The shape of a vibration is called the waveform. You can think of the waveform of a sound as a graph of the air pressure at a particular point over time. The waveform is an abstraction that we use to describe the sound. It happens to be an abstraction that has a lot to do with the tone's perceived quality.
A loudspeaker (speaker, for short) is a device that converts electronic vibrations into sound. In talking about electronic music and computers, we generally refer to electrical waveforms that exist inside an instrument's circuitry. When we refer to these waveforms as if they were sounds, we assume there's a speaker somewhere and that we're using it to produce the sounds.
A personal computer may contain its own small speaker (e.g., the Apple II), may use the speaker of the TV to which it is connected (e.g., the Atari or Commodore 64) or may require connection to an external sound system like most high-quality music synthesizers. Most electronic pianos, organs and synthesizers use "analog" circuits that produce smooth waveforms. Digital computer circuits, on the other hand, work by switching on and off.
How does a computer produce a musical tone? In most computers, you can turn the speaker on and off as if it were, say, a memory location. You can produce a tone by writing a simple program to a) turn the speaker current on, b) wait a very short time, c) turn the speaker off, d) wait again, and e) repeat the above steps a specified number of times. The waiting time determines the pitch of the tone, while the number of cycles of repetition determines its duration.
If the "speaker on" and "speaker off" times are the same, the resultant waveform is called a square wave and the musical quality is somewhat hollow, like that of a clarinet. If the "speaker on" and "speaker off" times are not the same, the waveform is called "rectangular" and the quality may be saxophone- or oboe-like. If the "speaker on" and "speaker off' times are programmed to change randomly, the resultant sound is a pitchless noise.
While any computer can produce square and rectangular waves, only those equipped with sound synthesizer circuits can produce more complex waveforms. Some sound synthesizers are built on single integrated circuit chips that can be progammed to produce a wide variety of waveforms and envelopes. (The envelope of a sound is its outline as it builds up, sustains and dies out.)
Other synthesizers are built on circuit cards that plug into the computer or may be completely separate peripherals. Computer programs enable musicians to design their own sounds. Musicians think of this type of programming as "building an instrument": the "instruments" exist as data that define waveforms and envelopes-and may therefore be stored in "libraries" on disk or tape.
Computer-controlled sound synthesizers may be all-digital (the waveform itself is generated from digital data), all-analog (waveforms are produced continuously by analog circuitry that responds to digital instructions) or a combination of the two (waveforms are converted from digital to analog form, then passed through analog circuitry). Digital circuits that produce waveforms handle numbers that represent a succession of points along a waveform. Analog circuits, on the other hand, handle voltages that change continuously to generate the desired waveform.
Digital circuits are more accurate and reliable than their analog counterparts. Since they produce waveforms from a series of numbers in time, however, the resultant waveforms are made up of steps that are often audible. Both methods of synthesis have their advantages and limitations; some musicians prefer the smooth, distortion-free analog waveforms, while others favor the accuracy and versatility of digital generators.
Playing the PC
There are simple programs for most personal computers to make scales and melodies through the computer's speaker. To use a typical progam of this kind, you type in codes for the pitches and durations of the notes.
More sophisticated programs enable you to vary the rectangular wave tone color, adjust the overall tempo, produce trills and glides, and store tunes that you have programmed on disk or cassette tape. Music Maker, a software package for the Apple II, produces the illusion of two notes being played simultaneously, generates sound effects as well as musical tones, and displays a colorful animated video pattern in time with the music. Programs like Music Maker don't produce complex or high-quality musical tones; their main uses are educational and recreational-you can learn a good deal about programming, train your ear and have a lot of fun, for a very small investment in addition to your computer.
By using a computer with a built-in sound synthesizer, or adding a digitally controlled synthesizer peripheral, you can make music with a wide variety of interesting tone colors. The Commodore 64 has one of the most versatile built-in synthesizers of any currently available personal computer. The "64" uses a proprietary chip that produces three tones with programmable waveform and envelope. The chip also contains an analog filter, a device that changes the tone color by emphasizing some of the sound's overtones and cutting out others. The resulting range and quality of sound rival that of some of the analog keyboard synthesizers available in musical instrument stores.
Some of the most musically advanced computer programs are designed around the Mountain Computer Musicsystem, an eight-voice digital tone generator for the Apple II. Among the more popular are the Alpha Syntauri and the Soundchaser systems. Both use the Musicsystem in combination with a professional-style four- or five-octave music keyboard and their own operating software.
With either of these systems you can make up your own sounds, play them from the music keyboard and record the keyboard performance. Since one part of the software sets the Musicsystem up to produce the desired tone colors and another part captures and stores the keyboard performance, you can play back your keyboard performance with a variety of tone colors, pitch ranges and speeds. Both the Alpha Syntauri and the Soundchaser can implement the basic functions of a multitrack recording studio. You can record a keyboard performance on one "track," then play that track back while recording subsequent tracks. The Syntauri Metatrak program, for instance, lets you record up to sixteen tracks, then play them back simultaneously. Fast Forward, Rewind, Record and Erase functions are implemented by typing one or two characters on the computer keyboard.
To a musician, using Metatrack (or the Soundchaser Turbotracks program) is closely akin to using a conventional tape recorder. To the average computer user, programs that implement a multitrack recorder are actually file management systems with real-time merging capability. Whichever way you look at it, Metatrak, Turbotracks and related programs offer potent musical resources to pro musicians-and a lot of musical enjoyment to amateurs.
In addition to simulating multitrack recorders, computer-based music systems offer other functions that are important to musicians. Music-teaching programs are available for both the Soundchaser and the Alpha Syntauri. Soundchaser's Musictutor package contains an array of ear-training exercises that not only sharpen your ears, but keep track of your learning progress. Syntauri's Simply Music program will teach you how to play a keyboard instrument in a variety of styles and at a pace that suits you. Once your keyboard chops are in good shape, you can convert your keyboard performances directly to a printed score with Syntauri's Composer's Assistant, a software package that enables a dot-matrix printer to produce conventional music notation.
The Roland Compumusic CMU-800R is an example of an analog musical sound generator designed for computer control. The Compumusic uses electronic piano, organ and synthesizer circuits to produce realistic percussion, bass, "rhythm" guitar and melody voices through your sound system. Using Roland-supplied software, you program the melody, harmony and rhythm from the computer keyboard. Then you "mix" the sounds by manipulating the volume sliders on the Compumusic unit while the computer "plays" the complete piece of music that you've programmed. The computer is not able to program the Compumusic waveforms since these are determined by the unit's analog circuitry. The advantages of Compumusic are in its high sound quality and hands-on-the-knobs control.
Musicians have expressed the desire to control a regular electronic keyboard by means of a computer. An increasing number of electronic pianos, organs and synthesizers are being adapted for computer control. For this purpose, the musical instrument industry has developed an interface called MIDI, the Musical Instrument Digital Interface. MIDI allows electronic instruments, computers and similar devices to be connected with a minimum of fuss. This means that, if your computer itself is equipped with a MIDI peripheral and the necessary software, you can use your computer to control any MIDI-equipped electronic musical instrument. You can even combine instruments into a computer-controlled "orchestra."
Will computers ever completely replace human musicians? A number of traditional instrumentalists, upon seeing entire string and horn sections replaced by synthesizers and other digital instruments, have asked this question. The answer lies in the fact that music is and always will be an aesthetic and emotional experience for humans and not for computers. There will always be musicians as long as there is a song in our hearts.
Herbie Hancock on the road with computer and clavier.
When I use a computer to make music, it's as if I have a partner-one that acts in a very logical way and appears to function like a human brain. The interaction causes a strange relationship. The computer gives me answers quickly and makes no mistakes. If I give it data that doesn't fit into what it can do, I say: "It doesn't like that." Or when it pauses, I tell myself: "It's thinking." There is definitely an intellectual challenge to make the computer do what I want. I have to communicate with it in a very specific way.
I use a Fairlight computer to create sounds I can't get any other way. I can digitize sounds from actual instruments and then modify their waveforms on the screen with a light pen. This doesn't mean I intend to turn my back on traditional acoustic instruments. I'll continue to play acoustic as well as electronic keyboards, because every instrument has its own touch, texture and nuance. It's just that synthesizers and computers are tools for making instruments the likes of which have never been heard before.
Some keyboard players are great performers on a synthesizer, but they don't know much about programming it. Others are good players and programmers. Thinking in musical terms can help develop your technique for programming computers. A musician thinks in terms of measures and themes; in programming you have to consider lines of code and routines. Of course, having manual dexterity also helps, since a prerequisite for using today's computers is the ability to key in commands. Someday, though, you'll be able simply to talk to computers with voice recognition.
In the future I'd like to be able to create music on-line with anyone anywhere in the world. Recently I saw a concert in Vancouver where the musician on stage was playing with two other people in Sydney and Tokyo. The only limitation was the speed of the electrons on-line-the speed of light. There was a slight delay in the audio, and the musicians had to take risks with their playing to stay in sync. But here they were, playing together on three continents! It made me look forward to the day when the electronic cottage will become an electronic bandstand.
HERBIE HANCOCK, creator of electronic keyboard albums including Headhunters and Future Shock
Digital computers are like farmers' tractors. A tractor is a source of mechanical power, with a few levers to control that power; it's nearly always used with specialized implements that may be simple (like a plowshare) or larger and more complex than the tractor itself.
A computer is a source of number processing power. Its own levers (the keyboard) give access to the power within. But it is the peripherals, like printers or digitally controlled synthesizers, that convert the computing power to some form of information or useful action.
To understand the difference between a personal computer with a digitally controlled synthesizer peripheral and a digital keyboard instrument available in music stores, let's carry our tractor analogy a little further. Many implements contain their own sources of power and perform their functions without being hooked to a tractor (examples range from lawnmowers to fifty-ton bulldozers). In these implements, built-in power is more efficient and convenient than separating the source of power from the specialized mechanical function that gets the job done.
Digital keyboard instruments are the musical counterparts to implements with dedicated power sources. At the heart of any digital keyboard is a specialized computer that is preprogrammed to perform a limited set of functions. The computer controls a digital synthesizer that actually produces the instrument's sounds. Although technically they are separate entities, computer and digital synthesizer are often built together and both are located inside the instrument. The player accesses the computer and plays the instrument by manipulating the panel controls and depressing keys.
Digital keyboard instruments come in all sizes. The smallest ones are portable, inexpensive and funoriented-our folk instruments of the eighties. Most have built-in drum rhythms, and can remember and play back what you play on the keyboard. Some of the larger ones are complete home music centers that read the music, then play one part while you play the other, or teach you how to read music and play the keyboard. Others, designed for professional musicians, have a wide variety of rich tone colors, touch-sensitive keyboards and performance-oriented functions. The best of them produce accurate simulations of strings, acoustic piano and guitar, and electronic musical sounds of extremely high sonic quality.
Up in the performance-price stratosphere are the "computer musical instruments"-large studio instruments controlled by full-blown dedicated computers. These instruments offer the state of the art in digital sound production and control. The Fairlight, for instance, records or synthesizes virtually any musical sound, then allows the musician to "play" the sound back at any pitch, either from its touch-sensitive music keyboard or from one of two special composing languages. The Synclavier, another superinstrument, is designed to develop sonically rich timbres by adding together "partial waveforms."
With any of these superinstruments, a musician working in a studio can start at synthesis of the sounds and end with a complete multipart piece of music. This is why the superinstruments have found extensive use in film, TV and commercial music production houses.
But are the superinstruments the ultimate computer musical instrument? Not by a long shot. Scientists and musicians at Lucasfilm have developed a multimillion-dollar system called the Lucasfilm Audio Signal Processor. The ASP is a completely digital recording studio, musical sound producer and film synchronizing facility all in one. In place of the time-consuming film sound editing and mixing traditionally done "by hand" to get music, dialog and sound effects into a movie or TV program, the ASP enables musicians and film sound people to computerize all aspects of sound track production.
Digital technology is entering every area of music and sound production. As digital audio disks and tapes become commonplace, we can look forward to hearing the highest quality of reproduced sound in our homes-sound that is limited in quality only by the loudspeaker itself. The promise for digital musical instruments is equally bright: warm, rich timbres, vast creative potential, exciting interactive computer-aided teaching and performing modes.
At the rate digital technology is advancing, musical instrument designers will soon have to deal with the same situation that digital audio engineers now face: the quality of state-of-the-art digital musical instruments will be determined not by the sophistication of the electronics within the instruments, but by how much the instruments' electromechanical components (loudspeakers, keyboards, control, switches and so forth) can be improved. The traditional skills of building vibrating structures, smooth-acting keyboards and all the other things associated with fine musical instruments are by no means dormant. They have been given new life and vitality through digital electronics.
Return to Table of Contents | Previous Article | Next Article